Tony's Pizza New York Style at 6975 A1A South #2, St. Augustine, St Augustine, Florida.

Our family was staying across the street, a few months ago, with another family, and we ordered two large pies, simply out of convenience. SO GLAD WE DID !!!!
They were so good we immediately ordered two more, saving one for breakfast, because that's how we roll.
The crust is PERFECT, the sauce is delicious, and everything is topped off with fresh herbs. Lots of places make good pizza but this guy attention to detail, makes for a great one That alone would have made me a lifelong customer.
In fact, thats why I stopped there the other day with four preteen boys who needed post surf pizza fuel. Food was delicious as always, but when it came time to pay, the card reader was down due to the Hurricane. I only had 8$ cash towards a 31$ bill. He asked me if I could tip the server and catch him next time we came by, even though he knew we were from another town, quite some distance away amd may not be able to settle up for a month or two.
Took care of us and his employee before himself. Tony is a stand up guy !!